Our Church Staff

Rev. Derek Hickman, Senior Pastor

330-562-8266 x 223

Derek is a native Ohioan, growing up in Newcomerstown.  He received his undergraduate degree from Kent State University in 2009 and his graduate degree in Theology from Ashland Theological Seminary in 2013. He was ordained in 2018 as an Elder in the East Ohio Conference of the United Methodist Church.

Derek’s pastoral duties began as a Youth and Associate Minister in Newcomerstown. He then served as a Senior Pastor in Ashland and most recently as the Senior Pastor at the First United Methodist Church in Ravenna, before being installed as Senior Pastor here at The Church in Aurora on December 1, 2019.

Along with leading worship services, Derek brings knowledge and experience in the areas of youth education and outreach.  He has a desire to help others grow deeply in their love for God and one another and believes he is a passionate advocate for local church ministry. 

 “My family and I are thrilled to be serving God and The Church in Aurora. The church’s long history of practicing grace is a witness to God’s character and God’s desire for the local church.  I am delighted to be an active part of the Aurora community and exploring ways that The Church in Aurora can continue its legacy of bearing witness to the love of God.” 

Derek and his wife Jenna, who is a teacher at Miller Elementary School in Aurora, have two children, a son Wesley, and a daughter, Hallie. 

Kevin_0111_1Rev. Kevin M. Horak, Associate Pastor

330-562-8266 x 222

Kevin is a native of northeast Ohio where he attended the University of Akron and earned a degree in Elementary Education. After teaching for several years, he entered Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary in Massachusetts where he received a Master of Religious Education degree in 1981. That summer, Kevin was called to The Church in Aurora, to serve as the Director of Christian Education—a non-ordained position responsible for church programming outside of the Sunday morning worship services for all ages.

As this role continued to expand, he enrolled part-time at Ashland Theological Seminary where he completed his Master of Divinity degree in the spring of 1988. Ordained by the Presbyterian Church, USA in 1989, The Church in Aurora extended a call to Kevin to serve as the Associate Pastor. He continues to serve in this capacity with an emphasis on pastoral care, education and details. His personal job description is to, “Love God, love people and bring the two together.”

Kevin and his wife Kathleen are proud parents and grandparents. When his free time affords, Kevin “plays” in the local Aurora Community Theater, located across the street from the church.

Liz_0182_1Liz Sutter, Director of Outreach and Education

330-562-8266 x224

Liz was born and raised in Aurora, having attended The Church in Aurora since childhood. She is overjoyed to be serving our church, which has served her well for many years. She received her Bachelor of Arts Degree in Sociology from Ohio University in 1995.

After having taught Sunday School at The Church in Aurora for many years, Liz became the Director of Christian Education and Youth in 2014. In 2020, her role expanded, as she worked with several Aurora community organizations to create the Aurora Community Relief ministry.  With this ministry, persons in need are provided with food and living assistance.

To work with the people of this church to become true disciples of Christ is such a blessing for Liz…a lifelong passion.  Her personal goal is to spread the word that God’s love is huge and available to everyone.

Liz currently lives in Aurora with her husband, Josh, and three children – Ben, Sam, and Chloe. When she is able, Liz enjoys reading, traveling, and skiing.

Lance Vene, Youth Director

330-562-8266 x225

Lance was born in Cleveland where he spent most of his life until attending college. He came to us from his previous church in Willoughby, where he spent 5 years working and rebuilding their youth ministry program. He was excited to join The Church in Aurora as it holds a special place in his heart.  This church was central to growing his relationship with Christ through the Chrysalis ministry.

Outside of church, Lance works full time in Marketing where he helps manage day to day operations for a company in Brooklyn Heights. He has come to The Church in Aurora to help grow and lead the Youth Ministry program. Lance lives his life by this mantra: “My life is devoted to saving your life.” He is continually excited to see how he can help the church’s youth grow, and  how they can help him expand his faith in return.

In his free time, Lance likes to spend time with his nieces and nephews, catch a movie, or hit up the golf course.

Kay Oxford, Church Secretary

330-562-8266 x221

Kay was born and raised in East Tennessee, where she resided until she met her husband Richard.

They became members of The Church in Aurora in 1999 and to this day feel so very grateful for the countless blessings this church has provided them.

Kay served as a Confirmation Class teacher from 2010-2018 and has volunteered for Workcamp (youth mission project), multiple Nutcracker Sweets (a past church fundraiser), Vacation Bible School and served on the Nominating, Fellowship and Receptions committees.  She joined The Church in Aurora staff in 2017 and holds a Business Management degree from Pellissippi State Technical College in East Tennessee.

She and her husband Richard have 2 children. 

Given any opportunity, Kay enjoys exploring God’s miraculous and precious world through freelance photography and reflective walks among trees, along a shore, on a mountain trail, and even in her own backyard.

Sally_0135_1Sally McGill, Minister of Music

Sally is a life-long Ohio resident.  She graduated from the Baldwin – Wallace University Conservatory of Music where she obtained a Bachelor of Music Education.

She became a public school music educator and worked in that capacity for a number of years.  Sally moved to Aurora in 1959 and joined The Church in Aurora the following year.  It was in 1964 that she assumed the duties of Minister of Music and this began her long tenure in that position.

Under her guidance and direction, the music program has prospered and grown to include six choirs – four choral and two hand-bell.  These choirs offer a musical opportunity for all age groups within the church.

In addition, she is a welcome volunteer on a number of church committees and serves as past-president of the Women’s Guild, an organization devoted to growing the fellowship and faith of women within the church.

Although she retired from directing at The Aurora Community Theater, this local Aurora institution remains near and dear to her heart.

Sally and her husband Lynn have six children, thirteen grandchildren and two great-grandchildren.

Sheryl Reynolds, Accounting Manager

330-562-8266 x226

Sheryl is a native of the Buckeye state and has lived here her entire life.

She holds a business degree from Malone College and has 20 plus years of church accounting experience.  In addition to her work here, Sheryl serves as the Treasurer of the Canal District of the United Methodist Church and keeps the books for two other churches.

When not crunching numbers, Sheryl can be found outdoors on the ski slopes or a bike trail, dependent upon the weather.  She serves as patrol for both of these recreations, in that she ensures that other skiers or riders are safe.

Sheryl resides in Hudson with her husband Tom.  They have two adult twin daughters.